Is there another choice on the poll? I would say most people do not normally vote for a Moderator. Sorry!
Looks to me like Bama's stronger on both offense and defense. Are those the players' ratings out of high school? If you have all freshmen playing, that might be important. But, a 3-star can turn into a 5-star after three years in a program. Many don't reach their highest potential until well into college.
Can you compare them by their draft ratings? That would be interesting to see. The LazIndex give Bama a 5-point advantage on the power ranking. He's seldom wrong.